A Sirius clue

msbeadsley msbeadsley at yahoo.com
Wed Sep 10 17:09:38 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 80366

<psychobirdgirl at y...> wrote:
> Did anyone else everythink, after reading OotP, that it was a 
> little too obvious that Sirius would be the one who would die, 
> especially considering the commonality of the saying "Dead Serious."

Yes and no.  I think JKR does some things some times that are "a 
little too obvious," but most of the time she doesn't.  Since I am 
basing my expectations not on what seems obvious but on the fact that 
she hardly ever *is*, I am double-faked out.  I hope that makes sense.

And while it could be said that Sirius seemed doomed, I was hoping so 
very hard to be wrong that it surprises me how anti-climactic JKR 
managed to make his death.  I mean, I spent all this time with my 
toes sort of curling, hoping it wouldn't be him (or Ron, or Hermione, 
or Dumbledore, or Hagrid), and on the edge of my seat, that by the 
time Sirius went through the veil (with so very little fuss), I was 
kind of wore out already.

Sandy, aka "msbeadsley"





More information about the HPforGrownups archive