No subject

fawkes970 sollecks970 at aol.com
Wed Sep 10 22:23:23 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 80405

<snip>Which scene - Hermione/Boggart? In the trunk? At the end of 
PoA? Are 
you suggesting that she lies about Boggat!McGonagall? It's not hugely 
clear to me, but I'm going to proceed as if all these variable are 
true. 
Firstly - I don't believe that Hermione is able to laugh at herself 
to a convincing degree to be able to create this lie, which exploits 
an often sniggered-at facet of her character. Particularly not if she 
has just had a traumatic experience.

fawkes:
I think heremoine would definately lie about her boggart. shes lied 
before ever since the first book when she takes the balme and lies 
about what happened with the troll to all of her teachers, so that 
was first year when she was most into shcool, and after that i think 
she realizes things are more important then school and would lie 
about that and because peopel think of her as such a school oriented 
person she would concoct this(weve seen how clever she is as well) 
that her boggart is rrelaed to school





More information about the HPforGrownups archive