Mistaken identity thread - confusion

[Hagrid]

No: HPFGUIDX 80675

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "sbursztynski" 
<greatraven at h...> wrote:
> Sorry, ...Can someone please explain to this confused person 
> how they got all this stuff about Snape and Lily and red-haired 
>  girls called Florence from a single line in GoF that didn't 
> mention names  (other than Florence's) or hair colours? And 
> what's this about Ginny's mother - I thought it was the very much 
> alive Mrs Weasley?

Mistaken ID in a nutshell
 a) Lucius Malfoy missed Arthur and Bill Weasley, but knew "all 
Weasleys have red hair" (*theory: so Aurthur's younger sis?)
 b) The motive for Sirius' prank against Snape (*theory) may have 
been a mistaken identity with another red head kissing Snape.
 c) Bertha gossiped and got hexed for it (*theory) so the hexer may 
have been Sirius who she gossipped to.
 d) LOLLYPOPs fans saw Snape didn't like Lily for being a mud-blood, 
but a Weasly would be pure blood. At least there is still a love 
interest in Severus's life.
 e) Ginny would have been born just before Harry was attacked, so if 
(*theory) Auther's sister was killed after Ginny was born, Molly 
would have taken her in willingly. Death Eaters were still strong, so 
Severus wouldn't have owned up to a love child with a Weasley.
 f) Snape must have had some reason for not going to the sorting 
ceremony when Ginny met the hat. 
 
Advantage of this theory is:
- LOLLYPOPpers are allowed for.
- The Sorting Hat wanted unity between the Hogwarts houses .. now we 
may find a strong member of DA, Ginny, is from Slytherin blood.

Problem: 
- Snape showed no emotion when Ginny was taken by the Basalisk
- Snape? Romantic? I'd rather get a mental picture of Hagrid and 
Maxime ... lol

aussie