FLINT? When Hermione arrived at Grimmauld Place for Christmas
RSFJenny19 at aol.com
RSFJenny19 at aol.com
Sun Sep 14 02:20:34 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 80722
This has always bugged me about Hermione's Christmastime arrival to 12
Grimmauld Place.
Note the time sequence:
1. Harry has the nightmare and they go to Grimmauld Place and spend the night
waiting to see if Arthur will live.
2. That morning (DAY 1), after the Weasley's take naps, they go to the
Hospital.
3. They get back and Harry goes to his room and stays there through the next
night (Ron's asleep in the room and Phinneas is "guarding" over him).
4. The next day(DAY 2), Hermione arrives midday.
Now note what Hermione says,
"Dumbledore told me what had happened first thing this morning, but I had to
wait for term to end officially before setting off."
So Hermione spent an entire day(DAY 1) wondering where the heck they all were
and DD told her "first thing" two days later(DAY 2)? Why would he not tell
her the whole first day, but then tell her right away on the morning of the
second day?
Or DD told her "first thing" the morning after it happened (DAY 1), which was
not "this morning" but the previous day?
I go with the second explanation, which is a bit FLINTy to me.
~RSFJenny
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive