Hermione the animagus

[benigs]

No: HPFGUIDX 80849

Hi! A few months ago, it has been discussed that there is a certain 
scene in the CoS movie that the writer left in since JKR said it will 
be important in the latter books. Many said that it must be the 
Polyjuice potion scene wherein Percy caught Crabbe and Goyle (Harry 
and Ron actually) wandering around the corridors. But I have another 
theory (I just watched the movie a few minutes ago :)) and I 
apologize if this was already discussed before...

What if the important scene is still related to the Polyjuice potion 
but it is about Hermione's potion turning out wrong when she turned 
part human/part cat?

If I never knew anything about the HP books and watched the movie, I 
would totally think that that scene is totally unnecessary since 
Hermione's turning into a cat did not serve the movie's story at all. 
She just turned into a cat then became normal again a few minutes 
later with no lasting consequences... That is why I think it is the 
important scene that can't be cut...

Maybe in books 6 and 7, Harry and company needs to investigate 
something and it requires a disguise that is complicated, an animal 
form perhaps? And Hermione discovers that her polyjuice potion gone 
wrong is a part of the process of becoming an animagi? So she 
volunteers to become an animagi and do the investigating? Or maybe 
all three become animagi themselves? Just my theory :)

--->Ben

ADMIN: Please remember when responding to this post to stick to discussion about the books, not the movies.  On this list, the movies should be used only as a catalyst to discussing the books.  If you want to talk about the movies, please take the discussion to HPfGU-Movie.

http://yahoo.groups.com/group/hpfgu-movie/