Undercover Percy: who notified Dumbledore?
hermionegallo
hermionegallo at yahoo.com
Wed Sep 17 21:38:21 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 81036
n_longbottom01 (81021):
(snipped)
Who notified Dumbledore about the change in trial date?
1. Percy
2. One of the Aurors who works for the Order could have seen Arthur
and Harry rushing off to the trial
3. Maybe Arthur had time to contact Dumbledore himself, after he
sends Harry into the courtroom alone.
4. Possibly some of the portraits of former Headmasters could have
been keeping an eye on Harry at the MoM
EXCELLENT points, all of them. I never considered anyone but Percy
or Shacklebolt, and I had a hard time crediting Shacklebolt because
he wouldn't have known beforehand (but he was in the office that
morning; we saw him speaking w/ Harry and Arthur, so he could have
seen them, got Dumbledore right away etc.)
Hickengruendler adds there is a portrait of a former headmaster near
the DoM, right by where the trial takes place.
I actually like the idea of Arthur doing it but wonder if he sat
right outside the courtroom the whole time. The portrait makes a lot
of sense, as does Grey Wolf's idea that it could have been Marchbanks
or Ogden (although I don't agree that the time and place change was
a "minor" matter at all).
I don't think we could cite Dumbledore's notification as evidence
that Percy is acting as spy, because of the clear possibility that
there are so many others who could have done this job. Which brings
me to another point: it seems Dumbledore has eyes and ears all over
the Ministry already. If Percy was doing something undercover, what
else could it be? It makes me think about what Arthur is up to (oh,
am I bringing that up again?) -- there are Unspeakables, there are
Aurors, there's the Order -- and Arthur has been doing something that
predates the Order and is critical to Dumbledore. I just don't know
what.
hg.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive