Snape giving Occlumency lessons

president0084 president0084 at yahoo.com
Wed Sep 17 20:21:36 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 81051

I for one find it hard to believe that Snape is the only person in 
the order that could off possibly taught Harry Occlumency.

everyone I think are in agreement that Snape is a spy. the fact that 
he reported to the Order during the summer aswell as harry 
saying "spying of Voldemort, that you job isn't it" don't have book, 
but it was something along that line.

So at present the think is that Snape put information that can't fall 
into Voldemorts hands into the pensieve. All except that Voldermorts 
Loyal Death Eater is helping The Boy Who Lived. We have seen 
Voldemort punish his supporters for much less, If this fact was 
discovered it would mean Snape Death.

So the only way I can make any sense in having Snape (only spy in 
Voldemorts ranks) give Harry the lessons is to PROVE to voldemort 
that he is loyal. By weaking Harrys mind. Thus securing himself 
within Voldy's trusted servents and prove he is indeed Loyal?

As for the memory Harry seen, I think he wanted Harry see it? Would 
you leave a child, teenager, in his room. With dangerous potions 
around, and his memorys lying less than 5 feet away. Bare in mind he 
suspects Harry of Stealing from him. COS & GOF. With it not make more 
sense to have Harry walk out of the roon before Snape.

Thanks for reading my 2 cent
Jim






More information about the HPforGrownups archive