Thestrals and seeing death (was: Deaths at Hogwarts?)
hickengruendler
hickengruendler at yahoo.de
Thu Sep 18 11:20:36 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 81059
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Fred Uloth <prof_uloth at h...>
wrote:
> You've covered all their arrivals, but what about departures? He
should
> have seen them at the end of book four after they said bye to Krum
and
> Fluer. What is the anti-Flint argument there? Harry hadn't come to
terms
> with the death?
This is exactly JKR's explanation. The death has to sink it. She also
explained, that the real reason for him not seeing the Thestrals was,
that she couldn't make him see the horses and then let it completely
unexplained until book 5. Imagine our reaction, if Harry suddenly has
seen mysterious creatures in the very last chapter. I know it would
have annoyed me, and I am satisfied with JKR's explanation. The only
thing I am not happy with, is, that she explained it in an interview,
and not in the book.
Hickengruendler
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive