Possible JKR "Inspirations" (was Re: Interesting Fact)
erinellii
erinellii at yahoo.com
Thu Sep 18 19:00:27 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 81087
JDR:
> At the end of the article, it says that Gaiman ends the "Books of
> Magic" series by having his main character's stepbrother going off
to
> Hogwarts, as a little salute to JKR. The other author cited very
> graciously supposes that JKR read her books when she was a child
and
> metabolized them.
>
> --JDR
Dianna Wynne Jones would be that author, and, actually, I thought
that was pretty funny, because I've read most of hers and they are
the least like Harry Potter of the three authors mentioned in that
article. They are about witches and wizards, and one of them (Witch
Week)takes place in a boarding school. That's it. The boarding
school isn't even specifically for wizard kids, just some kids in it
happen to be wizards. Well, first off, half the classic books
written in Britain have boarding schools. More than half, most
likely. That's just normal over there. And there are many, many
books about wizards and magic as well.
That's not to say that her books aren't very good. They are. But
she also says that they take longer to read than the HP books, which
is just pure nonsense. I finished each of the Chrestomanci books in
an hour, an hour and a half, tops. She's done a very good job of
capitilizing on the HP wave, but she is not one of JKR's sources.
JKR has been pretty upfront about books that influenced her as a
child. For instance, read "The Little White Horse" by Elizabeth
Goudge if you want to understand more about Luna Lovegood and her
possible role in Books 6 & 7. Luna is like a straight-up tribute to
the heroine of that book. And read "Emma", by Jane Austen, which JKR
also has said influenced her enormously.
Erin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive