Snape Is Not A Spy

[Hagrid]

No: HPFGUIDX 81180

--- "yui_olp" wrote:
> > 
> > SINAS: Snape Is Not A Spy.
> > 
> 2. Voldemort "saw" from under Quirrel's turban Severus saving 
> Harry's life during that Quiddich game. 
> Sorry, Voldemort would never buy it.

aussie says:

Snape can argue loyalty to the Dark Lord. 

He prtended to change sides and join the Order to give LV a spy close 
to Dumbledore. 

He has kept his faithful position to LV all these years making 
dumbledore trust him more.

He has never brought suspition upon himself unless he is sure it is 
an action that LV wants.

Snape didn't know it was Voldemort trying to kill Harry that 
quidditch match ... he thought it was p-p-poor, st-stuttering Prof 
Quirrel. LV never revealed himself to Snape that year, or Snape 
wouldn't have threatened Quirrel with, "You don't want me as your 
enemy, Quirrell" and "... decided where your loyalties lie."

Quirrel seemed to be after the PS/SS for himself or maybe the Gold 
producing aspect. LV didn't know at that time if he could tell Snape 
the truth while he was in such a vulnerable state.

Neither Barty Couch JR, Snape nor Scabbers moved a hand against Harry 
without LV giving specific orders even though they all had their 
chance at Hogwarts.