[HPforGrownups] Re: Death Eaters

[eowynn_24]

No: HPFGUIDX 81271



Potterfanme <fc26det at aol.com> wrote:
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "troublenbass" 
<Notyourpoet at b...> wrote:
> <snip> 
> I have a question - and I am not sure if it has been tackled in 
previous posts.
> 
> In GoF, Voldemort counts his Deatheaters:
> "And here we have six missing Death Eaters...three dead in my 
service. One, 
> too cowardly to return...he will pay. One, who I believe has left 
me forever...he 
> will be killed, of course. And one, who remains my most faithful 
servant, and 
> who has already reentered my service."
> p.651
> 
> Well, I know Crouch is the last one mentioned. Snape is either too 
cowardly or 
> has left forever - thus, who is the third?
> And who were the three that died?
> 
> Also, who is Sirius's brother...and where is he mentioned?

Susan:
I can only answer two of your questions,  Karkaroff is the one who 
fled the TWT when the dark mark burned.  Sirius's brother was killed 
by LV or one of his death eaters.

Eowynn:

Since your last question has been answered (canon pg 112 OOP US edition.)  I Will try and answer the other ones. I agree that Crouch Jr. was the most loyal servant and that he had returned to LV service, however I do not believe that Snape is one of the other two. Do we know for a fact that he wasn't there? I can't find any canon to say he was at the tournament, only that he was there after, and not until they reached Crouchs' office. There is plenty of time for him to get back, and explain to DD what happened and where he had been. So this is my theory, feel free to disagree. I believe that you have two options for the two missing DE, one is Karkaroff, and the other is Lupin. Which one is which I haven't quite figured out yet, mostly due to personal feelings. I hope that it is Lupin who has left him forever, but am afraid he is the one who was too cowardly to show up. ( second doubts now that Sirius is back and he as heard how strong Harry is. Possibly hoping for the second chance
 that Snape got.)Which leaves Karkaroff as the one who will die, probably by the hand of a DE, he wasn't important enough to be killed by LV. Any how those are my thoughts on the three missing DE; Lupin, Crouch Jr, and Karkaroff.

Eowynn






---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! SiteBuilder - Free, easy-to-use web site design software

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]