Musings and a question

dcyasser dcyasser at yahoo.com
Tue Sep 23 13:43:46 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 81366

> 
> Ginger here:
> I'm kind of going out on a limb, but it seems that Protego , which 
is 
> the Shield Charm used on pp 591-2 OoP, US edition is the same 
shield 
> charm taught by Hermione in GoF pp 608-9 US hardcover.  Snape only 
> says "a shield charm" in OoP, so there may be more than one, but 
> that's where my knuts, yen, nickels and loonies are stacked right 
now.
> Anyone care to correct?


Ooh, good one, Ginger, I didn't look back to GoF. Does it ever 
strike you as funny that Hermione helps Harry practice these and 
other charms in GoF but apparently, since he is teaching them to her 
in OoP, doesn't learn them herself? 

 -  dc, who is enjoying a dark, rainy morning purusing the 
Potterverse and who is lucky the hurricane didn't quite touch us 
altho they cancelled school anyway. 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive