Dumbledore's Bridge (was: Dumbledore's Philosophy (was MAGIC DISHWASHER...)

[arrowsmithbt]

No: HPFGUIDX 81787

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Geoff Bannister" <gbannister10 at a...> 
wrote:
 
> Thanks for enlightening me; very considerate of you. I think that 
> both Dumbledore and I would be lost on that one, not being resident 
> in the US. If he comes to the UK, perhaps Mundungus could sell him a 
> pig in a poke.


Take care, Sir! Or it will be wet towels at dawn! True Brit here!
It's not  just the Brooklyn Bridge, there was that misguided American
who bought London Bridge thinking it was Tower Bridge.  Now
re-erected in Utah, I think.

I don't take any of DD's statements at face  value. This one falls into
the same category as all the rest.

Consider,
The implications of this statement are either:
1. Lily loved Harry more  than any other mother loved her child, *ever*
so providing unique protection,  or

2. Every  child is so protected by mother love.
Which is patently rubbish.

Which one do you choose? 
(Advice: Not the first,  or at least not  publicly because the posters 
who are mothers are liable to rip your head off.)

Also, since that little chat, DD has admitted that  he did not think
Harry  was ready for the truth at that age and so lied or at least
very strongly and deliberately misled him. Are  you now certain
that the whole truth has now  been revealed? I'm not.

Kneasy