Crying wolf?

[fawkes970]

No: HPFGUIDX 81872

Kneasy: In CoS Tom Riddle sneers at Hagrid for trying to raise them 
> under his  bed. Odd that. They should be cubs only for one day in 
every 
> 28. No indication is given on how to repel or destroy them (note 
JKR 
Fawkes(me): I would like to see the canon where they say hagrid 
raises werewolf cubs under his bed......

Kneasy: For example, he is seemingly unaffected by Dementors. Why? 
> It would be understandable if he was in his animal form, but he's 
not. > The thrust of JKRs sympathy crusade is that he is still 
human, just > suffering from a disease. So why the immunity that 
only animals seem to > have? To argue that his mind has been altered 
by his illness is to > accept that he may no longer be human.
Fawkes: They never say he isnt effected. Of course he is effected, 
and he is also a fully trained wizard who has already been a member 
of the Order. You think he wouldnt know the Patronus? the patronus 
is why he wasnt effected on the train, and for the scene with all 
the dementors at the end of PoA: he wasnt there- he was in the woods 
as a werewolf.
> 
Kneasy: At the Shrieking 
> Shack he seems to know, before being told, what Sirius' story is. 
How? > On entering, his first action is to  disarm Harry. Why? Does 
he really > believe that at age 13 Harry could perform an AK? It 
requires no > persuasion by Sirius before Lupin accepts his story, 
even though for > twelve years the entire WW, including Dumbledore, 
has been confident of > Sirius' guilt. dd the fact that he 'forgets' 
to take his medicine and > we have a very odd episode, much mused 
over by posters. PoA is the only > book in the series where Voldy or 
his henchman has not made an > appearance to threaten Harry.  Or is 
it?
Fawkes: we have been over this many a time. Lupin is in his office 
while the entire scene with Padfoot on the school grounds takes 
place. He is looking at the map and sees Sirius' name on it. First 
he wants to go and get sirius, however he notices a fifth member 
with them: Peter. Without even thinking he knows what is going on 
and has to get there to find out the entire story w/o peter or 
sirius being hurt to the point where they cannot defend themselves. 
That simple.
> 
Kneasy:It's still  that name that bothers me. Unless, of course, his 
parents > were also werewolves themselves. Which means that they 
probably > infected him - "Ooops-a-daisy, my little poppet! Just a 
nip! It's for > your own good; then we'll be able to look after you, 
even when the moon > shines brightly!"> Doesn't sound like a JKR 
thing to me.
Fawkes: almost every name given represents the character being 
portrayed ast that time. Hence, lupin is given his name for being a 
werewolf in the story. You  are taking it way too far to suspect his 
parents named him when really: JKR did so just cool it with that 
one, thanks. 
> 
-adding my two cents: fawkes-