Favoring Crabbe & Goyle? [was:Re: OT: Drill Sergeant]

[nkafkafi]

No: HPFGUIDX 94844

>Carol:
> Did I answer all your questions, SSS? And can you and Neri answer 
mine
> (regarding evidence of actually, as opposed to ignoring, Crabbe and
> Goyle)?
> 
> Carol, who would have presented these opinions in her original post
> but wanted to hear from Neri first

Neri:
Carol, I agree that Snape ignores Crabbe and Goyle completely, but 
this is a BIG plus, considering the the kind of attention he pays to 
Harry and his friends. It really would be a tedious overkill for me 
to count here all the points taken, detentions, extra homework, 
terrorizing and cruel remarks that the Gryffindors get from Snape on 
a regular basis. If you're seriously claiming Snape doesn't practice 
favoritism, please find me a *single* case of him punishing, or even 
just frowning at Crabbe and Goyle (or at any other Slytherin for that 
matter). 

Thinking of this, I can see Harry refusing to take Slytherins into 
the DA in book 6, and Hermione convincing him otherwise by saying 
that he must not behave like Snape.

Neri