Clue that Dumbledore and Harry had a previous relationship...

justcarol67 justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Sat Apr 3 19:11:03 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 95066

> Siriusly Snapey Susan wrote:
> I almost wrote "who hopes he learns to confide in SOME ADULT" above 
> but didn't.  You're right that Harry has confided in H/R but note 
> that he didn't at the end of OoP.  He didn't feel he could talk to 
> DD or Hagrid, either--only Luna a bit.  Anyway, the reason I almost 
> wrote "adult," and should have, is because my concern is that he 
> turn to someone w/ experience, knowledge & power enough to help him 
> with some practical things along w/ emotional things. [Sorry, R/H, 
> I'm not sure you've got all that!]
> 
> I totally agree that it would be even sadder if Harry keeps all 
> these people at arm's length.  That he will is one of my great 
> fears!  [Partly because it would make reading book 6 in some ways 
> pretty unbearable.]

I agree that he should confide in Lupin, who of all people most
understands what he feels about Sirius. But given his tendency to
conceal his feelings (other than anger) as much as possible, I'm not
sure that he's ready to do it. I think that a first step would be
asking questions to gain knowledge, as he tried to do with Sirius (who
unfortunately, having been in Azkaban for twelve years, didn't have
all the answers). Then, having established that he can trust that
person to answer his questions, maybe he'll feel safe in confiding his
feelings. Being a boy in a stiff-upper-lip culture, he may still find
this difficult with Lupin, even if Lupin makes the first move. 

I think that Harry's first move will be to accept Mrs. Figg's
invitations to tea (which, like most of JKR's little hints, are not
dropped without a reason). He can ask her the questions he wanted to
ask in OoP and maybe, if he finds the answers satisfactory, confide to
a grandmotherly figure things that he can't confess to a man,
especially an admired man like Lupin, for fear of seeming weak.

Carol, who admits to never having been a teenage boy (but neither was JKR)





More information about the HPforGrownups archive