There seem to be a lot of life debts...

vmonte vmonte at yahoo.com
Tue Apr 6 00:04:01 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 95257

Carol wrote:
JKR's words are "late in life." Dudley, who will still be seventeen at
the end of Book 7 (his birthday is in June) doesn't qualify. My bet is
Mrs. Figg, who definitely does. Surely a Squib with life-long contact
with the WW has more chance of accessing latent magical powers than a
boy we've constantly been informed is a Muggle like *both* of his
parents and *all* of his grandparents? (Lily, we're repeatedly told,
is Muggle-born. Petunia, we're repeatedly told, is just a Muggle.
Dudley, therefore, can't possibly be a Squib, which requires at least
one magical parent, or a latent Muggle-born wizard with the power
squashed out of him.)

vmonte responds:
I hope it's not Mrs. Figg, I would rather that it be Petunia than 
Mrs. Figg, because it would be the worst thing that could happen to 
Petunia, and that would be a really interesting read.  
I do have a question: I'm not sure why Dudley (or anyone for that 
matter) would have to be a Squib in order to gain magical powers 
later? By the way, just because we are informed that Dudley is a 
muggle (or Aunt Petunia for that matter) doesn't mean that they are.  
They are only thought to be muggles because they haven't yet shown 
any magical ability.       







More information about the HPforGrownups archive