What does Christmas represent to the WW?
Jospehine
J.Z.Dench at uel.ac.uk
Tue Apr 6 10:41:14 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 95304
Geoff:
I agree that there are many people today who merely use these
festivals as an excuse for a knees-up and, I suspect that Ron and his
family may possibly be in that category whereas Hermione and Harry,
coming from a Muggle background may be more aware of what is really
going on.
jozoed now:
This topic has brought a lot of us out of lurkdom, and I too want to
reply. You have not mentioned another 'category' for people who
celebrate Christmas. I am not even slightly religious, and I don't
consider Christmas as an excuse for a 'knees-up'. What Christmas is
to me, is a tradition. I respect those that celebrate it for its more
religious reasons, but its essence for me is a time that everyone is
kind, respectful, and happy (if you are one of the lucky ones of
course). Christmas *is* an excuse to be generous, giving, and to
celebrate family. In the modern world, especially in England which is
far less religious than America, Christmas = family. I personally
think that this is what the Weasleys were brought up to believe
judging by the high moral standards Molly and Arthur demostrate, and
their emphasis on family loyalty. I would disagree with you that
Harry would be aware of what Christmas is about in the Christian
sense... I don't see the Dursleys being especially religious do you?
And I would bet that Harry spends more time at Christmas thinking
about his parents than Christ on Christmas day.
But I don't disagree with you totally- there are those who disregard
all meanings of Christmas and think only of the parties and presents!
This would most definitely apply to Draco and Dudley... but not the
Weasleys.
Sorry, couldn't resist a post on Christmas!
jozoed
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive