Snape, Lupin, and the map

khilari2000 hannah at readysolve.com
Sun Apr 18 20:00:17 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 96327

SB4E:
> > 
> > Who says that he doesn't know that Lupin is a werewolf?  This 
> memory occurred during their OWL exams, which take place very near 
> the end of the school term, so it would stand to reason that Sirius 
> has already played the prank on him....remember that they have by 
> this time become animagi...Sirius basically calls Wormtail a 
> dunderhead for not knowing the ways to tell a werewolf because he 
> has been running with one.  So it is very possible that Sirius has 
> already played the prank on Severus and he already knows that Lupin 
> is a werewolf by the time this memory takes place.
> > 
> 
Ginger: 
> 
> Additionally, Snape was the one who made the potion that helped 
keep 
> Lupin from turning into a werewolf.  This verifies that Snape does 
> indeed know he's a werewolf... he just may not have yet made the 
> connection about their nicknames.


I meant that he had not known about Lupin being a werewolf at the 
time of the memory, which he would have known if he had been 
listening. Not that he did not know in the present day. I apologise 
for being unclear.
It is true the prank might already have taken place, I hadn't thought 
of that.

Khilari.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive