Conspiracy Theories

[soccerboyatut2004]

No: HPFGUIDX 96603

> Carolyn:
> Jim, however strong your feelings, you cannot impose limits on what 
a list of 11500 adults is allowed to discuss. The great strength of 
> this group is its diversity and tolerance of opinions, and the 
> welcome it gives to any Harry Potter theories, provided they are 
> expressed within the Admin rules. 

StrongBad continues:
I feel the need to clarify.  I agree with Jim that some of the 
theories ignore themes, and information in the books.  For example, 
JKR's message of honesty on loyalty, as it should be applied to 
Sirius and Lupin.

However, I like reading and discussing said theories.  I might not 
think some of them hold water, and that they are grasping at straws, 
but that is what makes this group fun.  

I like the theories, even if they are ridiculously hard to swallow 
(mine included).  Keep 'em coming.


StrongBad (who will be greatly gratified when Lupin and Sirius are 
both good guys in the next books)