Crouch!Moody

[vmonte]

No: HPFGUIDX 96747

owelry2003 wrote:

I (respectfully!) don't see the trio being
permitted the use of the Penseive either. Their interactions are 
their key to finding links and patterns! It would be a diminishment 
of the story line to give them such a convenient tool for memory 
mixing (what memories do they have/share that could be combined to 
such a purpose anyway?).

vmonte responds:
I wasn't trying to imply that book 6 was just going to be a big 
flashback scene of books 1-5. I want the trio to interact as well. I 
do think however, that at least one of the trio will go over at least 
one memory and discover something they did not notice during the 
actual event.  

For example:
Some posters believe that Lupin killed Sirius at the MoM. I don't 
believe this, but lets say that Lupin did cast the fatal spell that 
pushed Sirius into the veil. If Harry goes over this scene, using the 
penseive, he will be able to see what he did not see the first time 
around. 

I've often wished that I could step out of myself during situations I 
know I didn't handle well. I think that Harry should go over the 
memories he has of Snape.  He may be able to notice something he 
couldn't while he was seething with anger.  

I think there are a lot of links and patterns the trio can pick up 
on -- in and out of the penseive.