[HPforGrownups] The Problem with Lupin (long) was Re: How Close Are Harr...

[Miss Melanie]

No: HPFGUIDX 96952



Batchevra wrote:\
The mistake that you are making is equating curiousity with 
questioning. A person can be curious and still not question certain 
people. If you notice, Harry questions his friends, but not adults 
because his questions are answered by his friends but not by adults. 

 

My (Melanie) reply:  So does Sirius come into both of those categories?  I mean honestly Sirius answered most of his questions and Lupin did as well.  There were others that don't answer questions, or rather don't like questions to be asked and that's people like Molly.  Dumbledore always gives fairly vague answers (with the exception of OOP).  It is possible that Harry knows what happened to the Evan's, I mean it's never directly stated but it is entirely possible that during one of these little discussions that Aunt Marge does so well they discussed Petunia's parents death.  I just have a hunch that he has some knowledge of what happened to them.  As for the Potters, that really bothers me to know end...I mean Sirius told Harry about his grandparents.  I can't believe he didn't say, what happened to them?  Maybe he was too concerned to find out how closely related the wizarding world really was.  Or even scarier, that in a really twisted way he is almost related to Draco.  I'll
 just attribute that to shock and never thought to ask again.  The poor boy does have a lot on his mind you know.  

~Melanie




		
---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Photos: High-quality 4x6 digital prints for 25¢

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]