Breaking the Goblet Contract

Sea Change nakedkali at yahoo.com
Mon Apr 26 03:24:23 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 96973

 bboy_mn said:

bb>Or, in simple terms, I tried to come up with a likely magical
bb>explanation as an alternative to the standard contract law
bb>explanation suggested by others.

__________

Sea Change responds:

This is interesting, but is slightly at odds with canon.

During the mermen trial, it seems to have been an expectation of some
that Harry had chickened out and wouldn't show up at all.  Only
Dobby's intervention woke Harry up in time to even be there.  I
presumed at this point that the 'magically binding contract' was
pretty loose.


Sea Change, who, if in Harry's place, would have used my forced
participation to play Fred-&-George-style elaborate practical jokes
instead of trying to win.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive