Neville's future role/Evil!Neville

[arrowsmithbt]

No: HPFGUIDX 97129

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Meredith" <msmerymac at y...> wrote:
> I looked over the last 10,000 threads or so, searching for an Evil!
> Neville theory/prediction (for today's purposes, he can just be Evil!
> Neville and not ESE!Neville). I couldn't find anything relatively 
> recent using the yahoo search, but we all know that doesn't mean 
> there isn't anything there. *rolls eyes* If anyone knows where in the 
> archives to find something similar to this, let me know. I'm am not 
> proposing Neville is already evil, or has been spying on our hero, 
> more that he may have a tendency to become corrupted, and that we may 
> have canon evidence that foreshadows this. 

Similar theory - Neville = Peter and will betray Harry (post No. 8762 
mentioned in Fantastic Posts)
I've also seen others since I joined the site (so they'll be in the last 30,000
posts or so), but can't recall when. 
There have been a few more where the Marauders have been compared to
the Trio+Neville in a sort of history repeats itself, but Neville!ESE has not
been highly regarded up to now.
I was sort of edging that way (to maintain my reputation as an enthusiast
for dirty deeds) with the thread that starts with post 87319-'The Sorting Hat',
a theory that really they all belong to different Houses and the sorting was
fixed, but it branched off into other lines. Pity. I could have upset a lot of 
posters.

Kneasy