Harry's dream about the Turban (was Re: Re: Neville and the Prophecy - VERY LONG)

snow15145 snow15145 at yahoo.com
Sun Aug 1 03:46:38 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 108350

Vivian replying to my previous post:
>snipped<
I also have a comment about the "in essence divided remark." Is it
possible that JKR added the bit about Ron's brain attack to get Harry
to start thinking about his past? What I mean is what if Ron has
some residual problems due to the attack in book 5. He may have
memories that he never had before, or he may behave strangely as
though he had a split personality. Could Ron's residual problem be
what makes Harry start to remember his own strange behavior as a
child? What if Ron states that he hears another voice inside of his
head and Harry acknowledges that he also hears a voice inside his
head at times. 

Snow:
Really good point! How will Harry be introduced to the fact that 
there is definatly someone or something inside of him that he needs 
to recognize? I really like your explanation to this!  

Vivian:
Hermione may ask some pointed questions that might reveal that this
voice is not Harry's conscious but something separate. Just a thought.

Anyway, who do you think the half-blood prince is if it's not Tom,
Voldemort, or Harry?

Is it GG who is now inside of Ron?

Snow:
I personally feel that Harry's ongoing conflict that lies within him 
is that of which was born in him as opposed to that of which was 
unwilling thrust upon him. I feel that Harry was born a true 
Gryffindor but the attack on him left some of Slytherin in him. 

Harry has a battle that exists and has existed within him self. Harry 
has a choice. To quote Dumbledore GOF " Remember, if the time should 
come when you have to make a choice between what is right and what is 
easy
" Harry, IMO, will choose what is right over what is easy 
because he always has, usually for someone else's safety. Harry is a 
true Gryffindor. 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive