SHIP:Hermione's feelings for Ron in OotP (Was: Re: Harry's first Kiss)
Jenni A.M. Merrifield
strawberry at jamm.com
Sun Aug 1 09:26:00 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 108369
Jim Ferer wrote:
> If I gave a lady perfume and she termed it "unusual," I'd be bummed
> out. You have to add something to it to get anything better out
> of it.
Jenni replies:
<laughs> Well, just goes to show what I know. I've always
preferred more unusual perfumes - the typical cloying flowery stuff
is just so boring. I guess I must have bummed out more than my fair
share of past boyfriends. :-P
> Jenni: "Who really doesn't understand the constant fascination of
> the SHIPers, but figures "to each his (or her) own"
>
> It's a great insight into the characters, and a measure of how
> great a job JKR does with them that we actually care about the
> love lives of fictional teenagers. Otherwise, SHIPing is
> completely indefensible.
Okay, I'll fess up and at least admit that I have personal
opinions as to whom likes who and why, so I have to agree with your
comment on JKR's skill at her art. I guess I just don't have the
patience to do the depth of research necessary to really do SHIPing
the justice it deserves.
For the record, and (quite seriously) without any deep analysis
beyond what my brain subconsiously decided after the first one or
two times I read through the series, I've just always felt that, as
it stands at the end of OoP:
* Ron definitely likes Herminone;
* Herminoe thinks of Harry as her best friend, thinks she likes
Krum, and really actually likes Ron;
* Harry was physically attracted to Cho, has never really thought
about Hermione "that way", thinks of Ginny almost as if she were his
own kid sister, and is, for lack of a better phrase, a free agent.
* Ginny grew out of her early crush on Harry and moved on (and
though I think Ron would like to see her move back, I doubt that's
even occured to her);
> Jim Ferer, who would have to be tortured to admit his interest in
> SHIPping.
Except on HP4GU, of course. ;-)
Jenni
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive