Just a comment about Lupin's malady.

[M.Clifford]

No: HPFGUIDX 108460


vmonte:
> >> (JKR better not do some weird time-travel thing where some of 
the Order go back in time to fix something, and Lupin ends up being 
the werewolf that bites baby Lupin as a child.) <<
>
huntergreen: 
> I'll second that. I've had enough time-travel to last me the 
series.

Valky:
I mean no offense by this as you are generally one of my favourite 
posters Hunter, but isn't that statement an exaggeration?

Just *how much* timetravel have we actually had in the series. Ok I 
start the count at one chapter then two chapters then....... thats 
it!

TWO CHAPTERS in um..... over a hundred! It's barely a full 
percentage of the entire series and yet there is *already* too much?

Please, I have absolutely no idea where anyone gets the notion that 
time travel has been overextended in the story. 

It sounds to me like personal bias.

Now don't get me wrong, I *am* biased in favour of more timeturning 
because I have a scientific and adventurous mind. I don't mind a 
challenging paradox myself, its good exercise for me. Frankly, the 
excellence that JKR put into creating the timeturned paradox 
sequence *did* leave me thirsting for more. But I am not posting on 
behalf of that at all, I promise.

I just want to know how so little can be too much all of a sudden?

Best to You All
>From Valky