Snape's Reaction to Harry assuming that he is a DE spy

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 108498

Vmonte responds:
> 
> This scene has always bothered me. It is interesting that Snape 
tells 
> Harry that he is "neither special nor important." I mean what a 
drag 
> it must be for Snape to have to work with Harry if he really feels 
> that he is a nobody and not important. Why is Snape working for the 
> order anyway? Is it possible that the only reason Snape is at the 
> school is to protect Tom Riddle who is trapped inside Harry? I 
wonder 
> if Snape's loathing for Harry started on the first day of school 
when 
> he realized that Harry's will was stronger than Tom's.


Alla:
Hi, Vivian!
Sorry but I have to say huh?  Could you ellaborate a little bit, 
please? I mean I am always up for a session of Snape's bashing, but 
how does him telling Harry that he is "neither special, nor 
important" translates into possibility of Snape protecting Voldemort?

I thought that Snape was him usual abusive self, when he said that. 
You know, always trying to humiliate Harry, put him in whatever place 
Snape thinks Harry should be,


But what you are saying translates in very ESE! Snape and I am having 
trouble believing it.

Vivian:

> Harry stands up to Snape in his very first potions class. He also 
> does not allow the hat to sort him into Slytherin. Why does Snape 
> tell Draco to use Serpentsorcia during the duel? And why does he 
have 
> a calculating, almost satisfied look on his face when he sees that 
> Harry has this power? 


Alla:


Oh, as we discussed it earlier, I believe that Snape told Draco to 
use Serpensotia, BUT I think he did it because he suspected that 
Harry is a Parselmouth and wanted to see for himself.


Vivian:
 
> I'm thinking that Snape knows something about what happened at 
> Godric's Hollow. What if Snape really put a stopper on death at GH, 
> by saving Riddlemort who vaporized and went into Harry. Maybe 
Snape's 
> comment in potions class about putting a stopper in death was 
really 
> directed to Tom. He let the Tom in Harry's head know that he saved 
> his life. (So in essence he tells Tom: 'I saved you, and I'm at 
this 
> school to protect you...' 
snip.
     
> So, Snape hasn't really been saving Harry all of these years, he's 
> been saving his master.  And according to Snape Harry is neither 
> important or special it's what is inside of him that is important. 
> 

Alla:

Well, it is possible as any other scenario, but again I would prefer 
it not to be true. Sorry!

Snape saving Voldemort from the beginning exceeds all my standards of 
evillness. :o) So, are you saying in effect that Snape is the real 
Dark Lord and Voldemort is in his debt?
I hope that "stopper in death" will play out in Harry's fate in the 
positive way (namely saving him at the end).

I have to say one thing, if it turns out to be true, your scenario 
will be very funny.