Snape's Reaction to Harry assuming that he is a DE spy
Casey
caseylane at wideopenwest.com
Mon Aug 2 20:02:08 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 108564
> SSSusan:
> He doesn't have to know his precise whereabouts nor the name of
the
> people he's living with nor any other specifics of Harry's
situation
> to get a SENSE of what Harry's life is like.
Casey:
Not really. Would Dumbledore actually want anyone to know that he
placed the hero of the wizarding world in an abusive home?
> SSSusan:
> I'm afraid I'm not buying this, either. I mean, why just find out
if
> *HARRY* "bothered" to learn anything as a child? Why not find out
if
> SEVERAL of the children did so, by spreading around the
questions?
> Instead, he asked three questions--ALL of Harry.
Casey:
For all we know asking those questions may be part of Snapes first
class every year, much like the "foolish wand waving" speach. I
imagine he started with Harry because he was their "new celebrity".
If Harry had answered something correctly Snape might have moved on,
but Harry didn't. Thus he could knock Harry down from his celebrity
status to that of a mortal. Then Harry back talked and confirmed
Snapes worst assumptions.
As for why Snape didn't ask about Harry's background, well, if he
doesn't ask about the other children why should he ask about Harry?
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive