Occlumency Lessons
aggiepaddy
aggie at raggie.freeserve.co.uk
Mon Aug 2 22:21:43 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 108601
~Yb
<<<<<<<SNIP>>>>>>>>>>
> On another thought, maybe it was a good thing Snape taught Harry at
> least a little about Occlumency. Harry has to clear his emotions in
> order to block out LV. Sure, it's easy when you aren't upset, but
> it's much harder when you are fighting with a teacher you hate.
> Harry would have a much easier time clearing his head with DD than
> with Snape, but do we think he will be calm and peaceful the next
> time he has to lie to LV? Probably not. Snape (inadvertently)
> showed him how hard it will be to stand up to LV.
Aggie:
I agree with what you're saying, which now also raises the question,
which teacher will bring the *most needed* results? Taken from your
post it seems that *Snape* will be the most effictive teacher, in the
respect of outcomes, not teaching ability. I hope this is making
sense, it's past my bed time!!! What I'm trying to say is that you
are right. LV is *not* going to make it easy for Harry and he needs
to learn to use Occulmency when he is angry and frustrated.
Dumbledore is not going to give him that platform to learn from,
whereas Snape will. I do think that if Harry calms down and
acknowledges that Snape didn't play as big a part in Sirius' death as
he (Harry) raved about then this situation *could* work out.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive