another wacko theory

[Cathy Drolet]

No: HPFGUIDX 108678

Meltowne:

"They didn't need a new device.  Didn't they also disappear later that 
evening after the match - when everybody got slit up and the dark 
mark was cast?  Maybe the boys, following the match, used a regular 
timeturner to go back and tell themselves what the outcome would be - 
just like we saw in the second Back to the Future movie."


DuffyPoo:

First I have to say I don't buy the F&G used a time turner to learn the outcome of the match theory, they're sneaky but I don't think they're cheats.  They were, after all, concerned about the wording of a letter so it wouldn't sound like blackmail.  And, as someone posted yesterday, cheating would put them in the Ludo Bagman camp.  It was him they were trying to get their money back from...if they had cheated as well....

Fred and George went into the woods with Ginny, with Harry, Ron and Hermione following right behind.  Then Harry, Ron and Hermione were separated when Ron tripped and fell.  They had a short conversation with Draco, then realized that Fred, George and Gnny were gone.  Fred and George wouldn't have time-turned back leaving Ginny behind in that chaos, or are you suggesting she's in on it too? ;-)

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]