Sally's Spirit WAS Re: Shared thoughts
boyd_smythe
boyd.t.smythe at fritolay.com
Tue Aug 3 17:45:53 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 108690
> Eustace_Scrubb wrote:
> One might also speculate whether the leap from Grindelwald to Tom
> Riddle was _precipitated_ by the former's defeat by Dumbledore...or
> whether in fact Dumbledore was only able to defeat Grindelwald
> _because_ Spirit!Slytherin had abandoned Grindelwald already.
>
> Oh dear, _more_ nagging questions!
boyd:
My problem with all of this is that Tom says in CoS that he spent five
years looking for the Chamber. So either 1) Salazar's spirit was stuck
in there and couldn't help in the search very much (or possess Tom
until he entered the Chamber), or 2) Salazar's spirit couldn't
remember how to get into the Chamber.
Or 3), the theory that Salazar's spirit has been "wandering" is wrong.
What am I missing?
--boyd
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive