Shared thoughts / DD -- foreknowledge?

kempermentor kempermentor at yahoo.com
Wed Aug 4 04:42:24 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 108771

Kneasy responding to Snow:

(Re Dumbledore) Sometimes his reactions to events are just plain 
wrong; they don't fit unless he already knew about what has just 
happened.  So far I've rationalised this by postulating that his 
plan *is* the result of fore-knowledge - he sees his plan in its 
entirety and he makes damn sure it runs on rails - no deviations 
allowed, though I think he's about to hit a rocky patch. Where 
this fore-knowledge comes from, I'm none too sure, but I hope like 
hell it ain't TT or I'll be banging on the bookshop counter demanding 
my money back.


Kemper now:

I don't think DD has fore-knowledge.  I think he's taking all the 
evidence he's aware of and anticipating LV's next course and planning 
according to LV's moves.  If there's another Time Turner, I'll be 
book burning.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive