F & G and the QWC bet (Re: another wacko theory)
onnanokata
averyhaze at hotmail.com
Wed Aug 4 16:30:14 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 108880
Meltowne:
> Maybe the boys, following the match, used a regular
> timeturner to go back and tell themselves what the outcome
> would be - just like we saw in the second Back to the Future
> movie.
Kelly:
> Unless I am remembering wrong, Ginny was with them, so I don't
> think they could have gone back then.
Dharma:
You are both on to interesting ideas here. Initially to me, it
seemed too risky for the twins to have Ginny with them while getting
into serious shenanigans. I'm now questioning my initial reaction
because, I remembered a few things from book 5.
In OotP Ginny says, "The thing about growing up with Fred and George,
is that you sort of start thinking anything's possible if you've got
enough nerve."
Has Ginny been involved in something with the twins that goes beyond
jokes, Canary Creams and Nosebleed Nougat? Have they taken any
substantial risks that Ginny knows of, other than testing their
Wizard Wheezes products? The choice of the word `nerve' is striking
to me.
Also, George says to Harry during his first visit to Grimauld
place, "Yeah, size is not guarantee of power. Look at Ginny." Then
George completes this thought with, "You've never been on the
receiving end of one of her Bat-Bogey hexes, have you?"
Where would Fred and George encounter Ginny using that hex? Is the
Burrow shielded from magic detection, or has she been getting into
things that only Fred and George know about away from home?
Could she have turned to the twins for tutelage at Hogwarts? Given
that Ron often treated her as nuisance and Percy was so stringent,
maybe the twins took up the task of looking after her and offering
her advice.
In my opinion, she could be more involved with the twins and by proxy
their schemes, than it appears at first glance. Since Harry's
knowledge of Ginny comes primarily through Ron and Hermione, we are
probably missing quite a bit of information. It is only in the last
book that Ginny has started to speak directly to Harry, thus limiting
our information as well.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive