Pettigrew Attacked Ron?

[Cathy Drolet]

No: HPFGUIDX 109201

Yb thinks:
"So I think Sirius did attack Ron in the tower, but he was looking for 
Peter. Why would Peter attack Ron as Sirius? LV isn't back, and has 
had no contact with Peter yet, so there would be no reason. Plus, 
Peter has spoent enough time in the dormitories to know whose bed is 
whose, so he couldn't have made a stupid mistake like going for Harry 
but accidently attacking Ron instead."

DuffyPoo:

But by the time Sirius attacked Ron, Crookshanks would already have known that Scabbers had faked his own death.  That was on Thursday and Sirius attacked Ron on the following Saturday.  However, I think Meri answered my question with this:

Meri
"I could be wrong, but I believe that this refers to Ron's injuries 
just following the Shreiking Shack scene, and to whatever spell it 
was that Wormtail used to knock Ron unconscious. I think that Snape, 
seeing Ron knocked out on the groud, infered that Black had done 
something to him, and told this version to DD. Harry (or Hermy) 
tells DD that it wasn't Sirius simply because it wasn't. And 
Pettigrew did attack Ron. That's all, I could be wrong."

I was working on my Snape theory and had one of those DUH! moments.   


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]