The wizard formally known as Godric Gryffindor was also Nicolas Flamel

vmonte vmonte at yahoo.com
Sat Aug 7 02:29:41 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 109231

SSSusan wrote:

Or are you saying that maybe GG made the SS and changed himself into
NF when he was 300-some years old? Doesn't sound very likely to me,
but do you have a reason why you think he would he do this?

vmonte responds:

Yes, I was implying this.  I don't know, I need to know the story 
behind DD's relationship with Flamel.  Was/is Flamel part of the 
Order? Or is he just a scholarly pal/chemistry partner of DD's?

Voldemort is obssessed with living forever, and DD is involved with 
longevity rocks and elixirs. Is it a coincidence? Or is DD and or 
Flamel interested in longevity because they have unfinished business 
with Voldemort (who won't die)? 

Who is Grindelwald? And why does the date of his defeat correlate 
with Tom's basilisk career?...and with DD showing up at Hogwarts? 
Didn't Voldemort say to someone that he has always been able to find 
men that would accept him into their hearts (big time paraphrasing)? 
Is he/has he been a parasite for some time? (If so, what happens to 
the people he lives off of? Are they discarded, or do they turn into 
Dementors?)

How long has Flamel had the PS/SS? Because if he could keep himself 
alive for 666 years (yikes) why not a thousand?  Is the Order of the 
Phoenix an ancient Order? Is it really ALL about SS and not about 
unimportant nor special Harry (just using Snape's thoughts here).

If Voldemort is SS why doesn't he know it? Or is SS now inside of 
Harry (due to the GH attack)?  I liked the image of Harry with steam 
coming out of his head during the PoA movie. Will Harry have to 
literally release something from his head? Is it just anger, or an 
entity? If it's an entity, where will it go? (I for one would hate to 
see SS inside of Snape!) 

I also liked the PoA movie image of Ron Weasley roaring, like a lion. 
I know everyone hates this idea but I think the brain attack will 
affect Ron. Did the brain belong to a Gryffindor?

It's possible that DD met Flamel in his youth. Was he an apprentice? 
Did Flamel teach Dumbledore transfiguration?  

Finally, has Flamel been keeping his identity secret by morphing into 
new characters every few hundred years or so? 

Vivian
 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive