Ron's Patronus (Warning Ron=DD)

ohneill_2001 ohneill_2001 at yahoo.com
Sun Aug 8 23:48:17 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 109391

vmonte wrote:
> 
> You are not making something out of nothing.  There is a reason why 
> JKR left this bit out.  JKR once said that she could not tell a fan 
> what Snape's patronus was because it would give too much away. I 
bet 
> Ron's patronus would also...
> My theory (and it's not popular) is that Ron is Dumbledore and that 
> they both have the same patronus.  

Now Cory:

But as of yet, we don't know what DD's patronus is either, do we?  We 
saw DD cast the patronus charm when the dementors showed up during 
the quiddich match, but we don't know what form it took.

Furthermore -- and I'm not arguing against Ron=DD as a theory; I'm 
not entirely sold one way or the other on that issue -- but if JKR 
*is* going the Ron=DD route in the story, it seems to me that 
inconspicuously revealing each of their patronuses is exactly the 
type of clue that JKR *would* give, doesn't it?

--Cory





More information about the HPforGrownups archive