Theory on Snape - MASSIVE

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 109393


> > Kemper wrote:
> Thank you so much for posting a well argued and written post!  I'm 
a 
> ESNE!Snape fan (Ever So Not Evil), so I disagree with your husband, 
> Nora, Magda and Charme. 
> Your theory makes sense in the Plot and Thematically.  And here's 
why:
> DD wouldn't hire some evil man to work with youth, and a character 
> can be unlikable and still be good because "it is our choices 
(snip) 
> that show what we truly are."  



Alla:

Oh, Dumbledore would not hire some evil man to work with youth? You 
know what is coming, right? :o)

Crouch!Moody, Quirrell, who brought Voldie to school and dumbledore 
failed to notice, etc....

Dumbledore does not know everything and I firmly maintain that Snape, 
if he is ESE! could conceal the truth from him. But, i don't really 
believe in ESE!Snape. I just believe in Dumbledore , who could be 
very stupid.