Theory on Snape - MASSIVE

[kempermentor]

No: HPFGUIDX 109423

Kemper wrote:
>> DD wouldn't hire some evil man to work with youth, and a character 
can be unlikable and still be good because "it is our choices (snip) 
that show what we truly are." << 
 
 
Alla responded:
 
> Oh, Dumbledore would not hire some evil man to work with youth? You 
know what is coming, right? :o)

Crouch!Moody, Quirrell, who brought Voldie to school and dumbledore 
failed to notice, etc....
Dumbledore does not know everything and I firmly maintain that Snape, 
if he is ESE! could conceal the truth from him. But, I don't really 
believe in ESE!Snape. I just believe in Dumbledore, who could be 
very stupid. <


Kemper responds:

Moody was hired before Crouch!Moody.  
I believe Quirrell accepted the job as well before he went out in the 
forest where LV was... though I'm not as positive on that one.  
Though Dumbledore can be tricked, he isn't stupid.