biggest SPOILER _ graveyard at Hogwarts
arielock2001
arielock at aol.com
Tue Aug 10 22:52:01 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 109625
Brenda wrote:
> Are you trying to give us some sort of riddle? ;P
yes. ;-)
> 1. Where did you find Lily's birthday, was that in the books?
No, her birthday has never been given in the books or in
interviews. It's a guess based on what we know about her.
> 4. "It's a birthday she shared with a friend" -- are you saying
>Lily and her friend were both born on Sept 30?
correct
>Who do we know that were born on that day? And we have yet
>to see Lily's friends specifically named in canon. Where are
>you getting these from?
That's part of the riddle.
> 2. Why do you have the year of death in question marks?
unless you suspect they died after the attack of Godric's Hallow.
No, there is just so much debate about the timeline, the actual
years for the story are not clear.
(http://www.hp-lexicon.org/timelines/timeline-mapping-tf.html).
> 3. "History likes to repeat itself in this series" -- what
>'history' are we talking about here? The plot that 'matters' in
>death/evil conquer will somehow must include Voldemort, IMO.
>Are you drawing similaries between Tom Riddle, Lily and
>Harry?
Plot points are used more than once.
> 5. "The definitions of all twelve can be found in your home
Library" -
> - are you talking about the astrology and the names of 12
horoscopes?
close, months.
> Please give us insights.
> And no, no one will take it away from you, hehe.
(giggles). Sorry. (blushes).
> Brenda, who has claimed:
- time-turner uses the math behind Einstein's Theory of
Relativity
you're on to something there. ;-)
Arianna
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive