Tonks a traitor? was: Is Lupin is James

[A.J.]

No: HPFGUIDX 109731

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, sophierom <sophierom at y...> 
wrote:
> Lissa wrote:
> "We've already had one masquerader.  And we have
> Tonks.  (Who all's got bets on her being the traitor
> this time?)"
> 
> Sophierom:
> 
> Ooh, I haven't heard this theory before.  Tonks a
> traitor? Are there previous posts on this? 

Galadriel Waters has some hints about clues apparently in OOTP, but 
not everybody has figured out the hints to our satisfaction.  From 
what I remember (there's a message board where people try to figure 
out what the clues and hints could mean), people wonder why she is so 
clumsy and if it is real, or an act, or someone feeling clumsy in a 
new form; what's the deal with the troll leg umbrella stand; what is 
the snout clue when she makes funny noses; 'pink' in her hair as a 
clue (cf Hagrid's umbrella and Umbridge's sweater).  Personally I'm 
not sure everyone is convinced that this all is supposed to mean that 
something is WRONG or EVIL about Tonks per se.  But to answer your 
question, yes, various people here and on other boards often find her 
suspect in some way.

A.J.