biggest SPOILER _ graveyard at Hogwarts

Bex hubbarrk at rose-hulman.edu
Wed Aug 11 20:10:37 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 109739

SSSusan asked:
> If this has been asked, I apologize.  But how can it NOT be July 
> (and, thus, Harry being talked about), if Harry was able to remove 
> the prophecy from the shelf?  
> 
> Or are you saying the prophecy *is* still about Harry & Voldy but 
> *also* about Peter, and that any of the three could have removed it 
> from the shelf?

Yb's turn:
I think a general agreement has been reached that Harry could take 
the prophecy ONLY because his name was on it, which was because 
someone put his name on it (an Unspeakable, for sure, maybe a Keeper 
of the Prophecies?), because DD and everyone else who knew about it 
assumed that, after the Godric's Hollow affair, Harry was "the One" 
mentioned in the prophecy. Peter wouldn't be able to mess with it 
because his name isn't on it. Whether the prophecy has anything to do 
with him or not is moot regarding removing the orb from the shelf.

~Yb





More information about the HPforGrownups archive