biggest SPOILER _ graveyard at Hogwarts
Bex
hubbarrk at rose-hulman.edu
Wed Aug 11 23:01:11 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 109769
Linda's brilliant musing:
> Do you think that a prophesy can be that easily manipulated? If
that
> was all that needed to happen, why not use the imperious curse on
> someone who could alter the names on the prophesy and have them
take
> it off of the shelves once it was realized that only someone named
> on it could remove it??
Yb's turn, though somewhat dimmer:
I see two scenarios. Here they are, least likely first:
1) The DEs and LV didn't think about that. (Not likely.)
2) They did, at least try. Lucius came down to Level 9 near the
beginning of OotP, making nice with all the hotshots and being mean
to Arthur. I think he was rattling his his change purse, too. Maybe
he tried to bribe the Keeper of the Prophecies that day. Then we have
that little incident with poor old Bode. He worked on Level 9 (we
learned that in GoF, Arthur called him an Unspeakable at the
Quidditch World Cup), so maybe he /was/ the KotP. Anyway, he wound up
in St. Mungo's, unable to speak coherently, move, whatever... My
thoughts are that someone put him under the Imperius curse to try to
change the name (or just take the orb), he started resisting, touched
it when he shouldn't have, and suffered the fate of the Prophecy-
stealers. Then, when he started to recover, someone sends him Devil's
Snare, and it kills him. That's what I think happened, unless there
is canon to make me look like a liar.
~Yb
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive