biggest SPOILER _ graveyard at Hogwarts

Pat eeyore6771 at comcast.net
Thu Aug 12 17:09:40 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 109876

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "cubfanbudwoman" 
<susiequsie23 at s...> wrote:
> M.Clifford wrote:
> > > > > >>Lily shares her birthday with someone alive?
> > > > > >>Still lost......
 

Pat here:

I found this to be very confusing and rather than posting sent an 
email--one of many, apparently.  Mainly because I had no clue what 
the clues meant.

Upon reading all the responses however, I've noticed that there is a 
huge error regarding Hermione.  If you go to the Lexicon and check 
Hermione's birthdate, it is not September 30.  It's actually 
September 19, which means that she is not Libra--she's a Virgo 
(August 23 through September 22).  (And if you know anything about 
Virgos, her personality fits that much better anyway, but that's 
hardly the point.)  Now, September 19th is more than half-way 
through the month, but definitely not at the end of it.  

I also don't understand the reference to Lily's friend who is still 
alive.  We've never been given any information about any of Lily's 
friends, unless it is Remus--I doubt that it would be Peter.  But 
the only reference to Lily having female friends is when Harry pokes 
his nose in the Pensieve and sees her in Snape's Worst Memory (OotP)-
-however none of those girls are named.

I find all of this interesting, but too criptic to be giving us any 
clues that we can actually work out, according to canon.

Can you explain some more where you are going with this?

Pat






More information about the HPforGrownups archive