Alice's resistance

aboutthe1910s aboutthe1910s at yahoo.com
Fri Aug 13 00:11:19 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 109900

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Steven Spencer"
<terpnurse at q...> wrote:
> Aggie wrote:
> 
> > Terpnurse:
> >>>> We know the French resistance cells during WWII relied heavily on 
> >>>> coded messages and ingenious ways of communicating those messages. 
> >>>> Could the gum wrappers be analogous to some of their 
> >>>> methods?>>>>>>>>
> >
> > Aggie:
> > When I first read this I wondered WHY they would need to pass 
> > information in this manner.  But then I got thinking (*always* a bad 
> > sign!!) and thought specifically about Alice and Frank.  They are 
> > trapped in their own minds and in the locked ward in St Mungo's, what 
> > if they (or at least Alice) feels that there is a dangerous
element in 
> > said ward.  Perhaps she thinks that one of the members of staff is 
> > trying to keep them from recovering!  That they are kept in a
state of 
> > 'insaneness' to stop them spilling the beans about something they 
> > know.  Perhaps it's someone using the imperius curse and Alice is, at 
> > last, fighting it.  We *know* that Bode died there, what if this 
> > wasn't an accident?  She may be using the wrappers as a means of 
> > 'resistance' communication, we don't know as Neville just puts it in 
> > his pocket and doesn't read them!!!
> >
> > Cuckoos? I think one's just flown over my nest!!
> 
> 
> Terpnurse:
> Oh my lord I just thought of something! Earlier, Kneasy said:
> 
> "What does Droobles do? It produces bubbles, spheres that remain stable
> for days. Spheres? What sort of clue is that? Where can we find spheres?
> In the Ministry, in the Dept. of Mysteries, of course."
> 
> Combined with what you just wrote, it occurs to me that there's another 
> type of sphere that Alice would likely be more aware of in her present 
> state. The light globes at St. Mungo's! JKR went into a bit of detail 
> describing those lights, twice! During both of Harry's visits to the 
> hospital. And you're absolutely right about Bode. He was on the same 
> ward as the Longbottoms, and presumably shared a nurse or healer with 
> them. Didn't Hermione even remark that someone at the hospital 
> should've recognized the plant for what it was? Perhaps the spheres 
> that Alice is possibly warning Neville about are those lights. Maybe 
> some sort of spy device, like a crystal ball? Or perhaps there's 
> something else inimical about them?



On mugglenet.com, there's a section on anagrams
(http://www.mugglenet.com/anagrams.shtml), and I'm sure many of people
on here have been there, but just to bring this up again as it
pertains to this particular post, the last anagrams listed is this
(I'm cutting and pasting):

"Drooble's Best Blowing Gum is an anagram of Gold bribe below St. Mungos
Very interesting...in book 5, Neville's Mum gives him a gum wrapper.
Is she passing on an important message?"

aboutthe1910s





More information about the HPforGrownups archive