Calendars was Re: biggest SPOILER

scoutmom21113 navarro198 at hotmail.com
Fri Aug 13 04:09:37 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 109923

Yb wrote:
>> Sooo... why would she give us Hermione's birthday on the website
and in-chat if it was a major plot point? She would at least have
hinted that Hermione's birthday is in September if it was at all
relevant to the plot, not just handed it to us. Giving us something
like that, especially with no hints in canon, implies that it will
probably never even make it into the books. <<

HunterGreen:
Not that I agree that Hermione could be "the one" (not only is it
supposed to be male, the 19th is not as the 'month dies', and I don't
see how her dentist parents could have defied Voldemort three times,
and I believe JKR has said at one point in an interview that we
wouldn't be hearing any more about them), but there HAVE been hints
in the books about what her birthday is.

Bookworm:
There was another boy the prophecy *could* have applied to before 
Voldemort attacked the Potters - Neville.  I don't remember any hint 
given in the books or interviews of when his birthday is. Oversight 
or plot devise?

Ravenclaw Bookworm





More information about the HPforGrownups archive