Longbottom's Torture to Insanity (Re: candy)

[Jo Raggett]

No: HPFGUIDX 109951

Kneasy:
>>>>Major Snip>>>>>>>  
> There's a fair chance that there is something in a prophecy globe 
> that concerns Neville. Alice blows bubbles and they remind her and 
> she's desperate to get the concept across to Neville. And I doubt 
> that the globe is the same one as that Voldy was after. Mind you, 
> it could be one of the two that were broken, the ones where we 
> didn't quite hear the prophecies they contained. Wouldn't put it 
> past JKR, being sneaky like that.


Aggie:
Do you *really* believe that? Or are you just throwing it out there?  
As you said, the two broken prophecies *could* be relevant and it 
wouldn't be at all surprising to find this out!!  *However*, if 
Neville's prophecy does not turn out to be one of these then I doubt 
it'll happen.

It is canon that Trewlawney has only made two prophecies, and we now 
know both of them.  IMO it is too late in the game to introduce 
another seer and just having a prophecy on the shelf already, without 
even a hint that it's there, is far too Blue Peter for me!  (Here's 
one I made earlier!! Apologies to non-Brits, Blue Peter is a 
children's show where they make things out of old toilet rolls etc.  
They show you how to do it and then go Da Daaa and then produce one 
that has obvioulsy been rather expertly made!) 

Does Alice actually blow bubbles?  Does she even chew the gum?  
Perhaps she justs unwraps them and gives the wrappers to Neville!