Tonks a traitor? was: Is Lupin is James

[demetra1225]

No: HPFGUIDX 110001

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "mizstorge" <lszydlowski at h...> 
wrote:
Don't know about anyone else's ideas either, but 
> I don't trust Tonks.  (snip)
> 
> -We know she's clumsy - but how did someone that clumsy get to be 
an 
> Auror in the first place? Or is her clumsiness a way to hide 
> activities which members of the Order might find suspicious? During 
> the battle at the Ministry, was she just trying to preserve her 
cover?
> As for her tripping at Grimmauld Place, awakening Mrs. Black's 
> portrait, was she actually looking for something - some magical 
> heirloom perhaps?
> 
> Maybe she's just a ditsy girl, but I'm very sceptical!

Demetra:  
I don't trust Tonks either, from my first reading of OotP I've always 
had the feeling that there was something just not right about her.  
She seems to try too hard to make friends with H,R,H and Ginny.  She 
is also awfully eager to help Harry pack up when the Advance Guard 
comes to get him from Privet Drive.  And this is the first time she 
meets him.  Then she uses magic to do it - knowing full well that 
Harry just got in trouble with the ministry for just that 
infraction.  
Funny how she comments on the extreme cleanliness of the Dursley's 
kitchen.  That was my first reaction to her clumsiness - she seems 
just a bit too clumsy, almost unnaturally so.