Is JkR about to reveal?
snow15145
snow15145 at yahoo.com
Tue Aug 17 22:22:58 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 110395
Eustace_Scrubb:
>snipped<
Once again, one wonders what Dumbledore offered Petunia in return for
taking Harry in? Can DD have given her the ability to tap into some
recessive magic gene in a case of dire emergency? Seems
far-fetched...could the ancient magic that protected Harry extend to a
one-time ability to use magic on Petunia's part? Maybe she doesn't
turn out to be a full-fledged witch.
I believe so with a big emphasis on believe.
This is the definition of the word pact:
Noun: mutual agreement: an agreement made between two or more groups
or individuals, either formally or informally, to do something
together or for each other
Dumbledore and Petunia formally or informally made a pact by doing
something together or something for each other. Does that sound about
right? Formally or informally wouldn't that require them to be
physically together when the agreement was made? Did they do
something together to create the pact or something for each other to
create the pact, or both?
I realize the following is based mostly on speculation but as we
don't have the next book it's about all we can do. I think it's
rather good actually; you'll have to let me know.
The missing 24 hours.
It very well could have been in this time frame that the pact between
Dumbledore and Petunia was made. The sketchy proof of this is in
Dumbledore's statement to Harry that she may have taken you
grudgingly ect. How would Dumbledore have known how Petunia had felt
if he had not personally witnessed how she reacted when she was asked
to take Harry? This private setup could have been to assure that
Vernon was unaware of the true circumstances behind why Petunia took
Harry and what she received for taking him also to ensure that she
would take Harry in at all of course sealed with a consequence if
ever she reneged. Not exactly sure what the consequence would have
been if she ever denied Harry houseroom.
When she surprisingly found the baby on her doorstep the next
morning, she could act appropriately having already thought matters
through. Vernon would be left in the dark except for what had been
written in the note left by Dumbledore and approved by Petunia for
Vernon's benefit. Vernon wouldn't know what Petunia received if
anything from Dumbledore along with the bargain she actually made
with Dumbledore. There could be a bit more than meets the eye with
the blood issue.
My next hypothesis is what Dumbledore had bargained Petunia with.
What could he have offered her or better yet what could she have
wanted in return in this bargain? A while back I thought it might
have been to ensure Dudley was not sent a letter from Hogwarts but
that matter has certainly been cleared up by JKR. The other thing I
thought of way back was that Petunia may have been a squib which of
course was denied by JKR with a but
so I'm going to harp again on
Petunia's surgically clean kitchen announced in most of the books.
This one is a far leap but could Petunia have asked Dumbledore for
Lily's wand and possibly a bit of magic to go with it? I told you it
was a far stretch but
I could see the most powerful wizard alive
accomplishing something to this degree especially if it was the
contingency for Petunia taking Harry. Petunia acted a bit jealous of
her sister's special talents and may have secretly wanted to have
those talents herself. Petunia would only be able to use this magic
in secret to do household chores or whatever while Vernon was at work
but one day little Dudley walked in and saw what she was doing. Oh!
so that's what little duddykins was seeing when the dementor
attacked. We all know how scared he is of magic. Couldn't resist
putting that last one in.
Snow-who thinks Petunia was a different person especially to Harry in
the baby stage, when Vernon wasn't around...I think he was left in
the dark quite a bit.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive