Godparents and Half-Brothers
evita2fr
Snarryfan at aol.com
Tue Aug 17 19:33:55 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 110412
> Stella wrote :
> > there is nothing in canon to suggest any resemblance between
> > Snape and Sirius other than the dark coloring. In real
> > genetics, facial structures of even half-siblings have
> > similarities. <snip>
> Del replies :
<snip>
> 2. We're not sure whether the narrator is being impartial when
> describing Snape and Sirius, or whether he's telling us how *Harry*
> sees them. Harry hates Snape and after the end of PoA he loves
> Sirius : he would never willingly acknowledge any similiarities
> between the two. But interestingly enough, the descriptions of
> Sirius we get at the beginning of PoA, when Harry does *not* like
> Sirius yet, are quite reminiscent of his descriptions of Snape.
Wow, I wasn't here from a moment. I use my cousin's computer to add
something quickly in Snape/Sirius half-brother theory.
>From Sirius himself:
"You know, I think I'd prefer if you didn't give orders here, Snape.
It's my house, you see."
It's *my* house. Why Sirius precise that ? And why Snape reacted
like he did (an ugly flush suffused Snape's pallid face.)?
There is something, here. Sirius searched to make Snape angry in
remembering him who receive the house. And it worked.
Christelle (who wondered why her family doesn't have a
french/english dictionnary and can't wait to use back her own)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive